These buttons are frustrating!

I've narrowed it down to the small switch "chip" inside the push button device that seems to be closing the circuit. But how can this be on all 5 buttons?! There's got to be something i'm missing.

To engage the spin CN2 4 5 6 and 9 must be disconnected. Any single one of these attached will not allow it to spin.

I just cant imagine the lines are messed up in all 5 of these.

Any ideas?! before i cut any more lines up for testing!